Skip to main content

Mobley v. Workday Explained: What the Court Has Ruled So Far

|May 4, 2026|Updated Nov 3, 2026|13 min read
Mobley v. Workday Explained: What the Court Has Ruled So Far

Quick Answer: Derek Mobley, a Black job applicant over 40 with anxiety and depression, alleges that since 2017 he applied to more than 100 jobs at employers using Workday and was rejected at the screening stage, once at 1:50 a.m., less than an hour after he applied. In February 2023 he sued Workday in the US District Court for the Northern District of California. On 12 July 2024 the court found it plausible that Workday acted as its employer customers' "agent", so the disparate impact claims under Title VII, the ADEA and the ADA went forward; the employment-agency theory and the intentional-discrimination claims were dismissed.

On 16 May 2025 the court granted preliminary collective certification on the age (Age Discrimination in Employment Act) claim only. People aged 40 or older who applied through Workday's platform since 24 September 2020 and were denied employment recommendations could opt in after notice. The opt-in period has since run: notice went out from 6 January to 7 March 2026, and the court accepted consent forms filed on or before 14 April 2026.

Where the case stands: As of 7 October 2026 (the date of the latest court order we reviewed), the court has preliminarily certified a collective on the age (ADEA) claim, about 15,000 people have filed consents to join it, the plaintiffs have asked the court to certify a class on race, sex, age and disability claims (hearing set for 9 March 2027), Workday must file its motion to decertify the collective by 10 November 2026, and the merits have not been decided.

This article was updated on 3 November 2026 from the court's orders on the docket (N.D. Cal. No. 3:23-cv-00770-RFL), each linked in the section "What Has Happened Since 16 May 2025". The latest docket entry we saw is dated 29 October 2026 and is a motion to seal, not an order. We did not read entries 436 to 443, filed between 7 and 29 October 2026, so any order among them is not covered.

Anything filed after that date is not covered, and neither are routine sealing, scheduling and discovery orders that do not change the status of the claims. The full docket is on the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse (case 44074).

Who Is Derek Mobley

The plaintiff in Mobley v. Workday is a single person whose application history reads like a stress test for the modern hiring funnel. According to the court's July 2024 order, Derek Mobley is an African American man over 40 with a bachelor's degree in finance from Morehouse College. He is also an honors graduate of ITT Technical Institute and Server+ certified.

Since 2010 he has worked in financial, IT help-desk and customer-service jobs. The order records that he has allegedly applied to more than 100 positions with companies that use Workday's screening tools since 2017, and that every one of those applications was rejected at the screening stage.

The pattern Mobley documented is what catches the eye. Mobley alleges that some rejection emails arrived at early hours in the morning, outside business hours. One landed at 1:50 a.m., less than one hour after he submitted his application.

The timing mattered legally. The court wrote that the sheer number of rejections and their timing, together with the allegations about biased training data, support a plausible inference that Workday's screening algorithms were automatically rejecting his applications based on something other than his qualifications. That is an inference at the pleading stage, not a finding of fact.

His complaint, filed on 21 February 2023, alleges that Workday's AI-based applicant recommendation system discriminates against applicants on three protected bases: race (Mobley is Black), age (he is over 40), and disability (he has anxiety and depression). By May 2025 four other plaintiffs over 40 had joined him on the age claim; the later additions are covered below.

The complaint frames Workday not as a neutral software supplier but as the active screener: the actor whose algorithm, trained on biased data, is alleged to have made the call. These are allegations, and Workday has opposed them in court.

Why Workday Specifically

Workday is not the only ATS in the market. Greenhouse, Lever, Taleo (Oracle), iCIMS, and SAP SuccessFactors all process tens or hundreds of millions of applications a year. Why is the landmark case named after Workday rather than one of them?

The record points to three things. First, scale. Workday's Global Workforce Report (10 September 2024) says that in the first half of 2024 customers of Workday Recruiting processed 173 million job applications, a 31% increase, against 19 million job requisitions, a 7% increase. Those are Workday's counts of what passed through its system; they do not say how many applications its AI scored or screened. Second, the product: the court's order of 16 May 2025 (Dkt. 128) describes Workday's Candidate Skills Match tool as reporting results to the employer as strong, good, fair, low, pending or unable to score, records Workday's statement that customers "may enable, disable, use, or ignore its many features," including its AI features, and says the proposed collective "already encompasses only individuals whose applications were subject to Workday's AI because the employer turned on AI features." Third, the pleading: Mobley alleges rejections from more than 100 jobs at a range of employers that all used one common platform. The court noted that the common denominator for those positions is Workday.

The case is therefore not an indictment of every ATS. It is an indictment of this particular vendor's algorithm, deployed at scale, across many employers, with, the plaintiffs argue, a disparate impact on protected groups. Other vendors are watching closely. The ACLU states that in late 2023 it filed EEOC class-wide charges against Aon and an employer over hiring assessments, and in September 2023 the EEOC announced a $365,000 settlement with iTutorGroup, whose tutor application software, the EEOC alleged, automatically rejected women aged 55 or older and men aged 60 or older. The agent theory in Mobley could be argued against other vendors; the named defendant happens to be the largest.

The "Agent" Theory: Why a Software Vendor Is on the Hook

The most consequential ruling in Mobley so far arrived not at trial but at the motion-to-dismiss stage. On 12 July 2024, Judge Rita Lin held that the complaint plausibly alleges Workday is liable as its customers' agent under Title VII, the ADEA, and the ADA. That decision is the spine of the later developments in the case.

The agent theory works like this. Title VII, the ADA and the ADEA each define "employer" to include "any agent of" an employer. The court reasoned that employers cannot escape liability by delegating traditional functions, like hiring, to a third party.

Workday argued that as a software vendor it is not covered. The court drew a line instead. It gave the example of a spreadsheet an employer uses to sort applicants by birthdate: the spreadsheet vendor would not be an agent, because the spreadsheet is not participating in deciding who to hire. Workday differs, the court said, because its tools are alleged to perform a traditional hiring function, rejecting candidates at the screening stage and recommending who advances.

The reasoning could matter beyond Workday. A vendor whose product is alleged to reject candidates or recommend who advances can point to this ruling as the model for a claim against it.

The limits matter just as much. It is a pleading-stage ruling by one district court, so it is not binding on other courts. It decides what the complaint plausibly alleges, not whether Workday's tools actually discriminate. The court also dismissed the employment-agency theory and the intentional-discrimination claims.

What the Preliminary Collective Covers

The 16 May 2025 order granted preliminary certification of a nationwide collective on the age (ADEA) claim. The collective is "all individuals aged 40 and over who, from September 24, 2020, through the present, applied for job opportunities using Workday, Inc.'s job application platform and were denied employment recommendations."

The court left the parties to meet and confer on what counts as a "recommendation". "Preliminary" is the lenient first step of a two-step process. Its only consequence is court-approved written notice to people who may wish to join. After more discovery, Workday can ask the court to decertify the collective and require each plaintiff to proceed individually.

The size of the collective is not established. In its opposition, Workday said that "1.1 billion applications were rejected using Workday" in the period at issue and that notice would invite "potentially hundreds of millions" of plaintiffs.

Those are Workday's figures for all rejected applications, not a count of the collective. The court answered that the estimate "ignores the qualifiers in the definition of the collective that will limit its scope", and that a large collective is no reason to withhold notice when Workday is plausibly accused of discriminating against many applicants.

Joining was by opt-in, not automatic: fitting the definition does not by itself make anyone a member. The court ordered the parties to confer on a notice plan. It said publication notice on social media, or electronic notice to applicants on Workday's platform, could be considered only if targeted notice cannot be accomplished. The later notice orders are summarised below, and the orders are archived on the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse under case number 44074.

Race (Title VII) and disability (ADA): the 12 July 2024 order allowed those disparate impact claims to go forward. The May 2025 certification order concerns the age claim only.

What Has Happened Since 16 May 2025

These are the later orders that changed the shape of the case, in date order. Docket numbers are the court's. Each link opens the order itself in the CourtListener archive of the federal court record.

  • 29 July 2025, Dkt. 158: HiredScore. Workday argued that applicants screened by the AI features in its HiredScore product (Spotlight and Fetch) are outside the collective. The court held that "The scope of the collective, at the preliminary certification stage, includes individuals whose applications were scored, sorted, ranked, or screened using HiredScore AI features", and left differences between the HiredScore and Candidate Skills Match algorithms to "the decertification stage".
  • 28 August 2025, Dkt. 166: opt-in plan. The court set a phased plan with a 60-day publication period, notice by social media paid for by the plaintiffs rather than on Workday's platform, and a third-party administrator to screen pre-opt-in forms. It said: "It will be Plaintiffs' burden at final certification stage to show that the Plaintiffs in the collective were not recommended for hire by Workday's AI features."
  • 7 November 2025, Dkt. 195. The court accepted the parties' agreement to proceed without any pre-opt-in eligibility determination, so "no third-party administrator is needed anymore". Short-form notice was still to go out on social media.
  • 2 and 5 December 2025, Dkt. 211 and Dkt. 216. The court approved the notice plan: notice and opt-in from 6 January to 7 March 2026, with consent forms dated no later than 7 March 2026, on the website workdaycase.com. It denied Workday's motion to stay the notice process, calling the harm Workday described "speculative at this stage".
  • 6 March 2026, Dkt. 267: Second Amended Complaint. The order records that on 6 January 2026 the court allowed the plaintiffs to add three named plaintiffs (Jill E. Hughes, Sheilah Johnson-Rocha and Faithlinh Rowe) and gender claims under Title VII and gender-, race- and age-based claims under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). It granted Workday's motion to dismiss in part and denied it in part. It again held that job applicants can bring disparate impact claims under the ADEA, and dismissed the FEHA claims and Hughes's ADA claim with leave to amend.
  • 14 April 2026, Dkt. 305: late joinder. More than 500 people had sent consent forms after the 7 March deadline. The court allowed everyone who submitted a form on or before 14 April 2026 to join and ruled: "Further leave to join will not be granted absent an individualized good cause showing." It ordered the opt-in website taken down by 15 April 2026.
  • 22 June 2026, Dkt. 360: Third Amended Complaint. The court granted Workday's motion in part and denied it in part. The FEHA claims continue, because a California connection is plausibly pleaded, and Hughes's ADA claim is not dismissed. Rowe's new race disparate impact claim and a claim about Workday's own hiring were dismissed. "No further leave to amend is granted."
  • 2 July 2026, Dkt. 376: no interlocutory appeal. The court denied Workday's request to certify for immediate appeal its ruling that job applicants can bring ADEA disparate impact claims. The court found substantial ground for difference of opinion on that question, but it "no longer appears that an immediate appeal would materially advance the ultimate termination of the litigation". Clarity, it said, "is best pursued through a post-judgment appeal". The order also says the public notice "resulted in thousands of opt-ins".
  • 13 July 2026, Dkt. 395: schedule. This is the docket text of the order; no PDF is in the archive. Dates it sets:
    • 14 September 2026: the plaintiffs' class certification motion.
    • 10 November 2026: Workday's opposition to class certification and its motion to decertify.
    • 8 December 2026: the plaintiffs' reply on class certification.
    • 6 January 2027 and 10 February 2027: the opposition and the reply on decertification.
    • 9 March 2027: the class certification hearing.
  • 8 September 2026, Dkt. 415: opt-in discovery. Magistrate Judge Laurel Beeler calls the case a "conditionally certified ADEA collective action" and records that "About 15,154 individuals filed consent-to-join forms". She ordered the opt-in plaintiffs to finish answering Workday's discovery about the jobs they applied for by 30 November 2026.
  • 7 October 2026, Dkt. 435: depositions. The latest order we reviewed. Judge Beeler let Workday depose 15 of the 38 opt-in plaintiffs who gave declarations for the class certification motion, for two hours each, between 15 and 30 October 2026.

One filing is a motion, not a ruling. On 14 September 2026 the plaintiffs filed their motion for class certification (Dkt. 418) under Rule 23 with four subclasses: African American applicants, female applicants, age under the California FEHA, and disability. The court has not ruled on it.

Where an earlier order was changed by a later one, the later one controls. For example, the administrator step in Dkt. 166 was dropped by Dkt. 195.

How the Age-Discrimination Claim Actually Works

The ADEA, passed in 1967, protects workers 40 and older from age-based employment discrimination. It applies to employers with 20 or more employees, to most federal employers, and, on the reasoning of the July 2024 order, potentially to a vendor acting as an employer's agent. The statutory bite is not subtle: successful claimants can recover lost wages, liquidated damages equal to lost wages where the violation is "willful," reinstatement, and attorney's fees.

For an AI-screening case, the typical legal route is disparate impact: the plaintiff does not have to prove the employer or vendor intended to discriminate. They have to show that a facially neutral practice, here, an algorithmic screening tool, produces a meaningfully worse outcome for the protected group. The plaintiffs allege that Workday's AI recommendation system discriminates against applicants over 40. In the court's words, the critical issue is "whether that system has a disparate impact on applicants over forty".

That question has not been answered. Further discovery is where evidence on the scoring data, the training data and any audits would be tested.

Workday opposed certification on several grounds. One was that employers can choose whether to use its AI features: by declaration it said customers may "enable, disable, use, or ignore" them, so there is no common decision, policy or plan.

The court disagreed at this stage. It found that Mobley had substantially alleged a unified policy, the use of Workday's AI recommendation system to score, sort, rank, or screen applicants. After discovery Workday can present evidence that the collective is not similarly situated. The order does not declare Workday's tools illegal.

What This Sits Next To: iTutorGroup and Aon

Mobley does not stand alone. Two parallel developments give the legal climate texture.

EEOC v. iTutorGroup (Civil Action No. 1:22-cv-02565) is an EEOC suit from 2022. According to the EEOC's lawsuit, iTutorGroup programmed its tutor application software to automatically reject female applicants aged 55 or older and male applicants aged 60 or older, and rejected more than 200 qualified US-based applicants because of their age.

On 11 September 2023 the EEOC announced that iTutorGroup would pay $365,000 to settle. The consent decree also requires training, a new anti-discrimination policy, and injunctions against age- or sex-based hiring and against requesting applicants' birth dates, with EEOC monitoring for at least five years. A consent decree settles allegations; it is not a ruling on the merits.

The ACLU charges against Aon target a different layer. The ACLU states that in late 2023 it filed EEOC class-wide charges against Aon and an employer that uses Aon's assessments, alleging discrimination based on race and disability on behalf of an autistic job applicant and other similarly situated applicants.

On 30 May 2024 the ACLU also filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission about three Aon products: a personality assessment, an automated video interviewing tool and a cognitive ability assessment called gridChallenge. All of this is the ACLU's allegations, not findings.

Read together, the three matters span the pipeline: the screener, the cutoff rule, and the assessment. None has a merits judgment. iTutorGroup ended in a consent decree, Mobley is undecided, and the Aon matters are allegations.

What Workday Has and Hasn't Said

Workday's public posture has been measured. The company has stated it does not make hiring decisions, that its tools surface candidates rather than reject them, and that customers retain control of cutoffs. It has announced internal bias-detection audits and committed to greater transparency. It has not released the audit results.

The gap between announced audits and published audits matters here. Workday is not unique: HireVue said on 12 January 2021 that early in 2020 it had removed the visual analysis component from all of its new assessments, and released the results of an algorithmic audit of one of its assessments in the same announcement.

In litigation, discovery is how audit history, training-data provenance and disparate-impact statistics that vendors have treated as confidential can reach the record. Whether that happens in Mobley is not yet known.

What This Means for Job-Seekers Practically

Two changes are real and immediate, and one door has closed. Three more things are likely but not yet certain.

Closed for now: the opt-in period for the age collective has ended. Consent forms had to be dated no later than 7 March 2026, and the court accepted late forms submitted on or before 14 April 2026. For anyone who missed that date, the court said "Further leave to join will not be granted absent an individualized good cause showing" (Dkt. 305). If you are 40 or older, applied through Workday's platform since 24 September 2020 and did not opt in, the docket (Clearinghouse case 44074) and a US employment lawyer are the places to check what remains open. Joining never guaranteed a recovery, and the merits have not been decided as of 7 October 2026.

Real now: the EEOC's Strategic Enforcement Plan for 2024–2028, published in 2023, names employers' use of automated systems, including AI, as a priority. The EEOC's AI technical assistance documents (May 2022 under the ADA, May 2023 under Title VII) were removed from its website on 27 January 2025, so check its current guidance. The statutes still apply, and anyone who suspects discrimination can still file a charge with the EEOC.

Real now: several US states have begun to act. New York City's Local Law 144 (effective 2023) requires employers using automated employment decision tools to have the tool audited for bias no more than one year before use and to publish a summary of the results. Illinois requires consent and notification for AI video-interview analysis.

From 1 January 2027: Colorado repealed and reenacted its 2024 AI law (SB 24-205) with SB 26-189, signed on 14 May 2026. It applies to decisions made on or after 1 January 2027, and employment is one of the decisions it covers. A business that uses automated decision-making technology to materially influence such a decision must tell the person beforehand. After an adverse outcome it must explain, within 30 days, the role the technology played, and on request offer correction of inaccurate personal data and, where commercially reasonable, human review of the decision.

Likely: vendor settlements, audit disclosures, and product changes as discovery in Mobley progresses. Likely: follow-on cases against the next tier of ATS and assessment vendors using the same agent theory. Likely: a slow shift toward employers requiring bias-audit certifications from the vendors they buy from.

How to File an EEOC Charge if You Suspect Discrimination

This section is descriptive, not prescriptive. None of it is legal advice; for a specific situation, consult a US employment lawyer.

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission accepts charges of employment discrimination at no cost. The deadline is 180 days from the alleged discriminatory act in most states, extended to 300 days in states that also have a state or local fair-employment agency. The clock runs from the rejection, not from the day you discover the cause.

The EEOC's online portal at publicportal.eeoc.gov walks through the process. You provide your contact details, the employer's contact details, the date of the alleged act, the protected basis (age, race, disability, etc.), and a description of what happened. If a vendor like Workday is identifiable from the application portal, name it; the reasoning in Mobley is one basis on which a vendor could be named alongside the employer, although it is one district court's pleading-stage ruling. The agency reviews the charge, often offers mediation, and either pursues investigation or issues a "right to sue" letter that lets you bring your own federal lawsuit within 90 days.

Documenting the rejection is the most actionable step right now, regardless of whether you plan to file. Keep the original job description, the application timestamp, the rejection email or notification, any vendor name visible during application, and any screenshots showing automated assessment steps. Without that record, both EEOC charges and class-action opt-ins become harder to substantiate later.

The Limits, What This Case Will Not Fix Overnight

It is worth being honest about scope. Mobley v. Workday does not ban AI screening, does not declare any specific algorithm illegal, and does not entitle every rejected applicant to compensation. Preliminary collective certification is a procedural step, not a verdict: it authorized notice to people who could opt in, and Workday has until 10 November 2026 to ask the court to decertify the collective.

The honest read: the 2024 and 2025 orders let the disparate impact claims move forward and put a vendor in the position of a possible defendant, and the 2026 orders kept the age claim in the case and let California-law claims continue. They do not decide whether Workday's tools discriminate. Whether any individual jobseeker's outcome improves depends on the discovery record and on what the court decides later.

FAQ

What is Mobley v. Workday in plain English?

A federal lawsuit filed in February 2023 by a Black applicant over 40 who alleges that Workday's AI-based applicant recommendation system led to his rejection from more than 100 jobs, on the basis of race, age and disability. On 16 May 2025 the US District Court for the Northern District of California granted preliminary collective certification on the age (ADEA) claim only: people aged 40 or older who applied through Workday's platform since 24 September 2020 and were denied employment recommendations could opt in after notice. As of 7 October 2026 (the date of the latest court order we reviewed), the court has preliminarily certified a collective on the age (ADEA) claim, about 15,000 people have filed consents to join it, the plaintiffs have asked the court to certify a class on race, sex, age and disability claims (hearing set for 9 March 2027), Workday must file its motion to decertify the collective by 10 November 2026, and the merits have not been decided.

Why is Workday the defendant if the employer made the hire?

Because on 12 July 2024 Judge Rita Lin held that the complaint plausibly alleges Workday is liable as its customers' agent under Title VII, the ADEA, and the ADA. Those statutes define "employer" to include "any agent of" an employer, and the court reasoned that Workday's tools are alleged to perform a traditional hiring function: rejecting candidates at the screening stage and recommending who advances. It is a pleading-stage ruling, not a finding that the tools discriminate.

Does the case mean AI hiring tools are illegal?

No. The case does not ban AI hiring tools and does not declare any specific Workday product unlawful. It lets the disparate impact claims go forward and, on the age claim, authorizes notice to a preliminary collective. Workday has opposed the claims in court. The merits will be decided on the evidence, including Workday's scoring data and audit history.

If I think I was screened out unfairly, what can I do?

If you are 40 or older and applied through Workday's platform since 24 September 2020 and were denied employment recommendations, note that the opt-in period for the Mobley collective has ended: forms had to be dated by 7 March 2026, late forms were accepted through 14 April 2026, and further joinder needs "an individualized good cause showing". The orders and docket are on the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse case file (case 44074). Anyone in the US who suspects discrimination by an AI hiring tool can file a charge with the EEOC within 180 or 300 days of the rejection. Document every job description, application timestamp, rejection email, and visible vendor name. None of this is legal advice, for a specific situation, consult a US employment lawyer.

Ready when you are

Find your ideal career match in 3 minutes.

12 questions. Full result with strengths, blind spots, and careers matched to your type.