Quick Answer: Your résumé was auto-rejected by AI. You have 180 days to file an EEOC charge under Title VII (race/sex/religion), ADEA (age 40+), or ADA (disability) at no cost via eeoc.gov/employees/charge. If you are 40+ and applied through Workday, note that the opt-in period for the Mobley v. Workday age collective has closed: consent forms had to be filed by 14 April 2026, and the court said it will not grant further leave to join without an individualized good cause showing. Immediately request human review from HR as a reasonable accommodation under the ADA. If the employer screens candidates in New York City, NYC Local Law 144 requires a published bias-audit summary and lets you ask in writing about the data the tool collects. On your next application, our advice is to have a person read your résumé first and tailor it to the posting (we found no primary source for the "75% of résumés are auto-rejected" figure).
First, Confirm You Were Rejected by AI
Not every fast rejection is an AI rejection. Three signals point to algorithmic screening. One: the rejection arrived within hours of you applying, not days. Two: the rejection email is generic with no feedback on your qualifications. Three: you applied to a mid-to-large employer (500+ employees) in a vertical that uses ATS software, financial services, tech, consulting, healthcare, corporate recruiting. Mid-market vendors are Workday Recruiting, Greenhouse, Lever, Ashby, SmartRecruiters, JazzHR. Large-scale: Workday (in the Mobley case Workday told the court that 1.1 billion applications were rejected using its platform in the period at issue). If all three signals fit, assume AI screening.
If you received a rejection email without a hiring manager ever reviewing your application, and the company uses one of these platforms, it is reasonable to suspect that the screening was algorithmic.
Timeline: Your 180-Day Window to File with the EEOC
The federal clock starts on the date you received the rejection. You have 180 days to file an EEOC charge. In some states with dual-filing agreements, the window is 300 days. Check your state's filing deadline on eeoc.gov/employees/charge. After this window closes, you can lose your individual right to sue. The charge is filed for free; no lawyer is required at the filing stage.
File immediately if any of these apply: (1) you are 40 or older; (2) you are a member of a legally protected race, gender, or national origin group; (3) you have a disability, including non-obvious disabilities like neurodiversity; (4) you believe the screening tool was biased against your protected group. We found no source on how often a charge about automated screening succeeds, and a lawyer can tell you whether to file.
Mobley v. Workday: Should You Opt In?
If you are 40 or older and applied for jobs through Workday's application platform at any time since 24 September 2020 and were denied employment recommendations, you may fit the definition of the Mobley v. Workday collective. Fitting the definition does not by itself make you a member.
The case was filed in February 2023. In July 2024 the court ruled that the complaint plausibly alleges Workday acted as its customers' "agent", so the disparate impact claims could go forward. On 16 May 2025 it granted preliminary collective certification on the age (ADEA) claim only. As of 7 October 2026 (the date of the latest court order we reviewed), the court has preliminarily certified a collective on the age (ADEA) claim, about 15,000 people have filed consents to join it, the plaintiffs have asked the court to certify a class on race, sex, age and disability claims (hearing set for 9 March 2027), Workday must file its motion to decertify the collective by 10 November 2026, and the merits have not been decided.
Joining was by opt-in, and that period has ended. The court approved a notice plan on 2 December 2025 and the notice ran from 6 January to 7 March 2026. On 14 April 2026 the court allowed consent forms filed on or before that date and said: "Further leave to join will not be granted absent an individualized good cause showing." If you believe you have a good reason for joining late, a US employment lawyer can tell you whether to ask. The orders are on the CourtListener docket and the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse (case 44074).
Workday told the court that 1.1 billion applications were rejected using its platform in the period at issue. That is Workday's figure for all rejected applications, not the size of the collective. The court said the estimate "ignores the qualifiers in the definition of the collective that will limit its scope".
Joining the collective did not guarantee any recovery, and the merits have not been decided.
Request Human Review as a Reasonable Accommodation
The moment you know you were auto-rejected, email HR or the hiring manager with this request:
"I am writing to request a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act. My résumé was screened by an automated decision system that may not have captured my qualifications. I request human review of my candidacy by a qualified hiring manager, at no cost to your company. I am happy to schedule a conversation at your convenience."
Do not claim a specific disability if you do not have one. We have not checked which kinds of request the ADA covers.
We have not checked what the ADA requires an employer to do with a request like this, and an employer may decline it. Treat it as a request, not a guarantee. Some hiring managers will say "our process is final." The EEOC and the Department of Justice each released a technical assistance document on 12 May 2022. The EEOC's press release says that software, algorithms and AI used in hiring "may result in unlawful discrimination against people with disabilities in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act", including by screening out applicants who could do the job with a reasonable accommodation. That is the basis for asking for a human second look.
Keep a copy of every email, including any reply.
What NYC Local Law 144 Says
We read the text of Local Law 144 of 2021 (NYC Council); it applies to an employer or employment agency that uses an “automated employment decision tool” to screen a candidate or employee “in the city”. It says it is unlawful to use such a tool unless: “1. Such tool has been the subject of a bias audit conducted no more than one year prior to the use of such tool; and 2. A summary of the results of the most recent bias audit of such tool as well as the distribution date of the tool to which such audit applies has been made publicly available on the website of the employer or employment agency prior to the use of such tool.” The employer has to publish that summary, so you can look for it on the employer’s website without asking. The law as we read it does not require the employer to disclose the accuracy of the tool, and an earlier version of this page was wrong to say it does.
For a candidate who resides in the city, the law requires notice that a tool “will be used in connection with the assessment or evaluation of such employee or candidate”, made “no less than ten business days before such use”, which must “allow a candidate to request an alternative selection process or accommodation”. It also says: “If not disclosed on the employer or employment agency’s website, information about the type of data collected for the automated employment decision tool, the source of such data and the employer or employment agency’s data retention policy shall be available upon written request by a candidate or employee. Such information shall be provided within 30 days of the written request.” The NYC DCWP page describes the law. We did not review the city’s rules under the law, and we did not review laws outside New York City, so we do not describe them.
If the employer is covered and has not published this information, you can send a written request to its HR department:
"Under NYC Admin. Code 20-871, I request information about the type of data collected for the automated employment decision tool used to screen my application, the source of that data, and your data retention policy. Please provide it within 30 days of this written request. I also request an alternative selection process or accommodation."
We found no source on what audit summaries typically show, or on whether an audit summary or an employer’s answer to a request like this would count as evidence in an EEOC charge. Keep a copy of your request and any reply.
What Actually Helps on Your Next Application
Now that you understand your legal options, what changes should you make to your résumé so the next AI screener does not reject you? This is where vendor advice ("optimise for ATS," "stuff keywords," "bold your accomplishments") often misleads. The evidence is more specific.
1. Human review first. Have a person (mentor, career coach, trusted colleague) read your résumé before you submit. A second reader catches errors, clarifies weak phrasing, and makes sure your achievements are specific enough for any screener (human or AI) to understand. Clean writing pays: in a field experiment with 480,948 new jobseekers on an online labour market (Wiles, Munyikwa & Horton, NBER WP 30886), those given algorithmic writing assistance on their résumés “were hired 8% more often”.
2. Keyword precision, not keyword stuffing. Our advice: research the exact job title and the skills section of the posting. If it says "Python development," use "Python development," not "software development." If it lists "Kubernetes," include "Kubernetes." Do not add keywords your job did not touch; they take space from real accomplishments. In Resume Now’s survey of 925 American HR workers, 62% say AI-generated résumés without customization are more likely to be rejected (an opinion, not a measured rate).
3. Formatting: clean over clever. We found no primary source for the "75% ATS auto-rejection" figure. Jobscan, which sells resume-optimization tools, writes in its ATS-friendly resume format checklist (read on 4 November 2026): “Avoid multi-column layouts, tables, and text boxes, as the ATS can scramble the information.” Our advice goes further: use standard fonts (Calibri, Arial, or Georgia), one-inch margins, your name, location, phone and email at the top of the page body (not in the page header), and clear section labels (Experience, Education, Skills). Avoid graphics, columns, boxes, and any design that relies on visual hierarchy rather than text structure. We found no study that measures how often a design is misread.
4. Customization for each job. In Resume Now’s 2025 survey (n=925, American HR workers, 28 March 2025), 78% say personalized details signal genuine interest and fit, and 62% say AI-generated résumés without customization are more likely to be rejected. Both are stated opinions, not measured outcomes. Our advice is to read the job posting word for word and tailor your Experience section to the specific role. For example:
- Generic: "Managed software projects and led teams."
- Tailored (if the job is looking for a PM in an e-commerce space): "Led team of 6 engineers on the checkout-flow redesign, cutting cart abandonment by 12% and increasing AOV by $18."
That one detail, "checkout flow," "cart abandonment", shows that you understand the domain. We found no study that measures whether it changes who gets an interview.
5. For non-native English writers: keep dated drafts. Liang et al. (reported by Stanford HAI) tested seven GPT detectors on 91 TOEFL essays written by non-native English students and found that they “classified more than half of TOEFL essays (61.22%) written by non-native English students as AI-generated”. That was a test on essays, not résumés, and we found no source showing that employers use a detector as a hiring gate. If you write in English as a second language, keep draft versions of your résumé and timestamps to show you wrote it yourself. If you believe an employer rejected you because of an AI-detection flag, you can file an EEOC charge; this page does not say how such a charge would fare, and the study is context, not proof about any specific detector.
6. Do not let AI write your entire résumé. This is the most common mistake. ChatGPT and similar tools are useful for: refining weak sentences, expanding a bullet point with specific outcomes, personalizing cover letters, and brainstorming accomplishments you might have overlooked. They are not useful for: writing your entire résumé from scratch, generating fake accomplishments, or inflating your job duties. A wholly AI-written résumé is generic and sounds like every other AI résumé. Use AI as a drafting tool, then have a human (you, a coach, a mentor) rewrite it in your authentic voice.
If You Believe the Bias Was Based on a Protected Trait
The sources cited below concern three groups: people aged 40 and over, Black and women candidates, and non-native English writers. They are evidence about those groups. None of them is a court finding that an employer's screening was unlawful, and the main age case, Mobley v. Workday, has not been decided on the merits.
Age (40+). In EEOC v. iTutorGroup the EEOC alleged that the company's tutor application software automatically rejected female applicants aged 55 or older and male applicants aged 60 or older. The settlement, announced on 11 September 2023, was $365,000.
In Mobley v. Workday the court granted preliminary collective certification on the age (ADEA) claim only, on 16 May 2025. As of 7 October 2026 (the date of the latest court order we reviewed), the court has preliminarily certified a collective on the age (ADEA) claim, about 15,000 people have filed consents to join it, the plaintiffs have asked the court to certify a class on race, sex, age and disability claims (hearing set for 9 March 2027), Workday must file its motion to decertify the collective by 10 November 2026, and the merits have not been decided. The 1.1 billion figure is Workday's own count of rejected applications, not the size of the collective. If you are 40+ and think you were rejected because of your age, file an EEOC charge within the deadline above.
Race. The University of Washington / AIES 2024 study (more than 3 million comparisons) found that three open-source text-embedding models significantly preferred White-associated names in 85.1% of 27 tests and Black-associated names in 8.6%. NBER WP 29053 found that distinctively Black names reduced the probability of employer contact by 2.1 percentage points across 108 Fortune 500 employers. The UW/AIES authors also report that changing the name frequency-matching strategy "can alter whether Black names or White names are favored in a majority of cases", and the study does not show that any commercial screening product behaves this way. The NBER study measured employer contact in an audit study, not AI screening. Neither is a finding about your application: if you have a distinctively non-white name and think an automated tool rejected you, you can file an EEOC charge, and these studies are background, not proof.
Gender. The same UW/AIES study first reported that male names were preferred over female names. On 30 August 2026 the authors revised the paper to say that a bug in their code inverted the gender-only results, so the 52% first published for male names and the 11% for female names refer to female and male names respectively. Reuters reported in October 2018 that an experimental Amazon recruiting tool, built by a team working since 2014, penalized résumés that included the word "women's"; according to Reuters it was trained on résumés submitted over a 10-year period, most of which came from men, and Amazon said the tool "was never used by Amazon recruiters to evaluate candidates". If you are a woman and believe you were rejected because of your sex, you can file an EEOC charge.
Disability or neurodiversity. The EEOC and the Department of Justice each released a technical assistance document on 12 May 2022. The EEOC's press release says that software, algorithms and AI used in hiring "may result in unlawful discrimination against people with disabilities in violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act". The ACLU states that in late 2023 it filed EEOC class-wide charges against Aon and an employer that uses Aon's assessments, alleging race and disability discrimination on behalf of an autistic job applicant and others. These are the ACLU's allegations. If you have a disability or neurodivergence and the screening tool did not account for accommodations or legitimate alternative assessments, file an EEOC charge and request human review as a reasonable accommodation.
Finding an Employment Lawyer
Many employment lawyers offer free initial consultations. You do not need a lawyer to file an EEOC charge (it is free and online), but a lawyer can help you understand whether your case is strong, what evidence to gather, and how to respond if the EEOC investigates. When you call, tell the lawyer: (1) your protected status (age, race, gender, disability, national origin); (2) the employer name and ATS vendor if you know it; (3) the rejection date and any documentation you have; (4) whether you have already filed an EEOC charge or are considering one.
Look for lawyers with experience in employment discrimination or EEOC cases. Your state bar association's referral service can match you with local practitioners. Legal aid societies in many states handle employment discrimination cases pro bono for income-qualified applicants.
The strongest cases are ones where you can show: (1) you were rejected quickly without human review; (2) the employer uses a known AI tool (Workday, Greenhouse, etc.); (3) you fit a protected group with documented bias (age 40+, Black, female, disabled); (4) the tool was not validated on your demographic group (check the audit data you requested under NYC LL 144). The EEOC and courts are now taking these cases seriously.
Next Steps
Your priority order should be:
- File an EEOC charge (deadline: 180 days). Go to eeoc.gov/employees/charge. It takes 15 minutes and is free. Choose the statute that fits your claim (Title VII for race/sex/religion, ADEA for age, ADA for disability, or multiple).
- If you are 40+, check if Workday screened you. Email HR and ask: "What ATS system was used to screen my application?" If Workday, follow the Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse docket (case 44074) for the court-approved notice and any opt-in deadline.
- Request human review from HR while the employer still has the job open. Frame it as a reasonable accommodation request.
- Request the audit summary (if you are in NYC or a state with an AI-hiring law) or ask under EEOC guidance what bias testing the employer has done on their tool.
- Consult an employment lawyer if the EEOC investigation opens. Free consultations are available; search your state bar referral system.
- On your next application, apply the tactics: human review first, keyword precision, personalization, and honest AI use (as a refiner, not a writer). Consider taking a Career Match assessment to validate that the role is a genuine fit before optimizing your résumé, a polished résumé for the wrong role still fails.
The EEOC, federal courts, and state regulators are now treating AI-screening discrimination as a priority. You have legal recourse, and the precedent is on your side if you fit a documented-bias group. Document everything, file within 180 days, and do not assume a rejected application is the end of the story.