Skip to main content

Personality Assessments in Hiring: What Employers Are Looking For

|March 10, 2026|Updated Nov 3, 2026|8 min read
Personality Assessments in Hiring: What Employers Are Looking For

The Rise of Personality Testing in Hiring

Surveys put the use of personality tests in hiring at roughly one in five employers: a 2011 poll by the Society for Human Resource Management found that 18% of 495 HR professionals used a personality test when hiring or promoting employees, and the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development's Resourcing and Talent Planning 2024 survey found that 18% of UK organizations used personality or psychological questionnaires. Employers that use them typically do so to complement interview-based selection, since unstructured interviews have lower predictive validity (r = .38) than structured interviews (r = .51) (Schmidt & Hunter, 1998).

Understanding what personality assessments measure, how they are used, and what employers are actually looking for helps candidates approach these tests more strategically, and more honestly.

What Employers Are Actually Measuring

Professional personality assessments used in hiring are not looking for a single "perfect" personality type. They are typically assessing:

Role fit: Does your personality profile match the behavioral requirements of this specific role? Sales roles require different profiles than analytical roles. Management roles require different profiles than individual contributor roles. Employers develop role benchmarks, descriptions of the personality profile associated with high performance in a role, and compare candidates to those benchmarks.

Culture fit: Does your personality align with the organization's culture? High-growth startups may benchmark for high-Openness and tolerance for ambiguity. Traditional banks may benchmark for high-Conscientiousness and low risk-taking.

Derailers: Some assessments specifically screen for personality patterns associated with leadership derailment, the dark triad traits (narcissism, Machiavellianism, psychopathy), extreme emotional volatility, or interpersonal behaviors that damage team function. These are assessed through dark-side personality inventories like the Hogan Development Survey rather than standard Big Five assessments.

The Major Hiring Assessment Contexts

Graduate/Entry-Level Hiring

At this level, personality assessments are used primarily for culture fit and trainability screening when candidates have minimal work experience. Conscientiousness, intellectual curiosity (Openness), and Emotional Stability are the primary screening dimensions, they predict training success and early career performance in data-scarce candidate pools.

Mid-Level Professional Hiring

Here, assessments focus on role-specific fit. A sales hire will be assessed for Extraversion, achievement motivation, and resilience. A technicath, detail orientation, and independent work capability. A manager hire for leadership style compatibility, conflict management approach, and team orientation.

Executive and Leadership Selection

The highest-stakes assessment context uses comprehensive instruments like the Hogan suite, combining bright-side strengths, dark-side derailers, and values measurement. Organizations at this level understand that the personality characteristics that enable someone to reach senior leadership (confidence, assertiveness, risk tolerance) can become liabilities (arrogance, recklessness, narcissism) under pressure. Nuanced derailer assessment is the primary value here.

Preparing for Personality Assessments

The best preparation is self-knowledge, not test manipulation. Understand your own Big Five profile before encountering employer assessments. Know your strengths and their shadow sides. Be able to articulate your work style preferences authentically. Take the Big Five test and DISC assessment to understand your profile, not to learn what to say in a hiring test, but to develop the self-awareness that makes honest responses to any personality assessment coherent and confident.

The AI Layer Sitting On Top of Personality Testing

Personality assessments now sit downstream of an AI résumé screen. ResumeBuilder (n=948 business leaders, Oct 2024) reports that 51% of companies are leveraging AI in hiring and says “Today, 82% of companies use AI to review resumes” (it does not state the base). Capterra (n=3,256 across 11 countries) puts global HR-AI adoption at 55%. Bias in that upstream layer is now legal-risk material: the 2024 University of Washington / AIES study (Wilson & Caliskan, three open-source text-embedding models, 3M+ résumé–job comparisons, NIST-funded) found White-associated names significantly preferred in 85.1% of 27 tests vs 8.6% for Black-associated names; the authors' August 2026 revision says a bug in their code inverted the gender-only results, so the 52% first published for male names and the 11% for female names refer to female and male names respectively. EEOC v. iTutorGroup ($365K settlement, announced 11 September 2023) and Mobley v. Workday (preliminary collective certification on the age claim only, 16 May 2025) show that enforcement and litigation are live. The full evidence base, with a named source for each figure, is in our hub: AI Resume Statistics 2026, sourced stats on AI hiring, ATS, and bias.

For teams & organizations
Free assessments for HR teams

281 tests for hiring, onboarding, and team development. No per-employee fees, no certification.

See HR team plans

Ready when you are

Find your Big Five personality profile in 4 minutes.

50 questions. Full result with strengths, blind spots, and careers matched to your type.