Many verbal reasoning tests of this kind give you a short passage and a statement, then ask whether the statement is true, false or cannot be said from the passage alone. The verbal section of the JobCannon SHL-style practice test uses exactly that format, with the three options always in the order True, False, Cannot say. The method below turns a vague feeling into three checks you can run in well under a minute.
The one rule: the passage is your whole world
Every question comes down to one instruction: base your answer only on the passage. You are not asked whether the statement is plausible, sensible or true in real life. You are asked what the passage lets you conclude.
That has two consequences. First, a statement can be completely correct in the real world and still be the answer Cannot say, because the passage never established it. Second, a statement can look odd and still be True, because the passage makes it certain. Your job is to find the line, or the simple arithmetic on the lines, that decides it.
A five-step method
- Read the passage once, with a pencil habit. Notice numbers, quantity words (all, only, some, most, at least, more than) and conditions (if, unless, only if, must).
- Read the statement and say its claim to yourself. In your own words: what exactly is being asserted, about whom, how many, when?
- Find the sentence that deals with the same thing. If you cannot find one, that is already a strong hint for Cannot say.
- Run the three checks. Does the passage make the statement certain? Then True. Does it make the statement impossible? Then False. Does it leave the statement open? Then Cannot say.
- Test your answer. Imagine someone saying "show me the line". If you can point to it, keep your answer. If you are pointing at your own opinion, change it.
What each answer means
- True: the statement follows with certainty, sometimes after simple arithmetic on figures the passage gives. Likely is not enough.
- False: the passage rules the statement out. It contradicts a line, or the numbers cannot add up to what the statement claims. Unlikely is not enough.
- Cannot say: the passage is silent or leaves both possibilities open. The statement might be true or might be false, and the passage does not decide it.
Four worked passages
All four are written for this article and are not questions from the test.
Passage: "Riverside Swimming Club runs three sessions on Saturdays. Each session has 24 places, and this Saturday every place was taken." Statement: "72 places were taken at Riverside Swimming Club this Saturday."
Answer: True. Three sessions of 24 places make 72, and the passage says every place was taken. The passage never prints 72, but it makes 72 certain. Arithmetic on figures the passage gives is allowed. Outside facts are not.
Passage: "Hartley Parcels promises delivery within two working days for orders placed before 3 p.m. An order placed after 3 p.m. is treated as placed on the next working day." Statement: "An order placed at 4 p.m. on a Monday is treated as placed on Monday."
Answer: False. Four o'clock is after 3 p.m., so the passage says the order is treated as placed on the next working day, which is Tuesday. The statement says the opposite. False does not mean "unlikely". It means the passage rules the statement out.
Passage: "The Silver Bridge Music Festival is held in Lyon every June. Tickets go on sale each January." Statement: "The Silver Bridge Music Festival takes place in France."
Answer: Cannot say. The passage names a city and never names a country. You may well know where Lyon is, but the instruction is to use only the passage, so what you were given neither confirms nor rules out the statement. If you catch yourself thinking "but obviously", that thought is the outside knowledge the rule excludes.
Passage: "Only members who have completed the safety briefing may use the climbing wall. Tom has not completed the safety briefing." Statement: "Tom may use the climbing wall."
Answer: False. The briefing is required, and Tom does not have it, so he may not use the wall. Notice what a small change does: if the passage had said Tom had completed the briefing, the answer would be Cannot say, because the rule says what you need, not that having it is enough, and nothing says whether Tom is a member.
Slips that cost points
- Using outside knowledge. The passage is the only evidence. A real-world fact is not a line in the passage.
- Reading Cannot say as False. A statement that is not mentioned is not contradicted. Silence gives Cannot say, not False.
- Mixing up needed and enough. "Only" and "must" describe what is required. They do not promise that meeting the requirement is sufficient.
- Shifting a quantity word. "At least 54" is not "exactly 54", and "most" is not "all". Check that the statement uses the same strength as the passage.
- Skipping the arithmetic. When a statement gives a number, work it out from the passage's figures before you decide.
- Treating "after" as "because". A passage that says one thing happened and then another changed does not say the first caused the second.
- Answering what the passage "suggests". A strong hint is still not certainty. If the passage only suggests it, the answer is Cannot say.
Where to practise
Six more original passages, with the reasoning for each answer, are in true, false or cannot say: six practice passages with answers. The SHL-style practice page has the question types to work at your own pace, and the verbal reasoning test gives a longer single-skill run. To see how you do with 40 seconds a question, take the JobCannon SHL-style practice test.
The clock matters as much as the method, so read how to pace a timed reasoning test next. JobCannon is not affiliated with or endorsed by SHL Group Limited. SHL is a trademark of SHL Group Limited, and the result of this test is a practice score and not an official score.