Most percentage mistakes in numerical reasoning are not arithmetic. They are choices: which number is the base, whether the question wants points or percent, whether two changes can be added. Each slip below comes with an example that was checked by program. They are the same slips the numerical section of the JobCannon SHL-style practice test is built to catch, and the SHL-style practice page has more of the format to try them on.
The rule in one line
A percentage change is the change divided by the starting value. Everything else in this article is a way of getting that one line wrong, or of using it when the question wanted something else. If you read numerical reasoning from tables, this is the "choose the base" step in detail.
Slip 1: the wrong base
A price rises from £80 to £100. The change is £20. Divided by the starting price, 20 out of 80, that is a 25 percent rise. It is tempting to divide by £100 and write 20 percent, which is the size of the change relative to the new price, not the rise.
Now reverse it. A price that falls from £100 to £80 has fallen by 20 out of 100, which is 20 percent. So a 25 percent rise and a 20 percent fall are the same £20 movement seen from different starting points. Always ask which value the question starts from.
Slip 2: points mistaken for percent
If the share of homes with a smart meter goes from 8 percent to 10 percent, that is a rise of 2 percentage points. As a percentage change it is 2 out of 8, a rise of 25 percent. Both statements are correct, and they are not the same statement.
The same works downwards. If satisfaction falls from 42 percent to 35 percent, it has fallen 7 percentage points, and the percentage change is 7 out of 42, a fall of about 16.7 percent. When a question asks "by how many percentage points", subtract. When it asks "by what percentage", divide the difference by the starting value.
Slip 3: successive changes
A 20 percent rise followed by a 20 percent fall does not bring you back. Start at £500. A 20 percent rise gives £600. A 20 percent fall from £600 is £120, which leaves £480. That is £20 below the start, a net fall of 4 percent. The second change is taken from the new value.
Discounts behave the same way. A £250 coat reduced by 30 percent costs £175. A further 20 percent off the reduced price takes off £35, leaving £140. The total reduction is £110, which is 44 percent of £250, not 50 percent. Taking 50 percent off £250 would give £125, so the two-step answer sits £15 higher. Do the changes in the order given, one at a time.
Slip 4: working backwards
A price after a 20 percent increase is £90. What was it before? The tempting move is to take 20 percent off £90, which gives £72. But £90 is 120 percent of the original, so the original is £90 divided by 1.2, which is £75. Check: 75 plus 20 percent of 75 is 75 plus 15, which is £90.
A sale price works the same way. A sofa costs £60 in a sale of 20 percent off. The £60 is 80 percent of the original, so the original is £60 divided by 0.8, which is £75. Adding 20 percent to £60 gives £72, which is the wrong answer again. When a percentage change has already been applied, divide by the multiplier to undo it.
Slip 5: compound growth is not simple growth
A balance of £1,000 grows by 10 percent a year for three years. It is not 30 percent more. Year one gives £1,100, year two £1,210 and year three £1,331. That is a rise of 33.1 percent, because each year's growth is taken on a larger balance. In multiplier terms, 1.1 times 1.1 times 1.1 is 1.331.
A quick sense check helps here: with a steady percentage rise, the total over several periods is always a little more than the percentages added together.
Slip 6: mean versus median
Five commuters take 10, 12, 14, 15 and 49 minutes to get to work. The mean is the total, 100 minutes, divided by five, which is 20 minutes. The median is the middle value when the numbers are in order, which is 14 minutes. One long journey pulls the mean up and leaves the median where it was.
A question will name the measure it wants. If you read "average" and the options include both 20 and 14, check whether the question says mean, median or neither, and answer the one it names. If it says only "average", the safe reading in a numerical test is the mean, but look for any wording that says otherwise.
A two-second check before you commit
- What is the base, and is it the starting value?
- Does the question ask for points or for percent?
- Was a change already applied, so that I need to undo it?
- Are two changes in a row, so that the second works on the new value?
- Does the answer have the right size and the right unit?
Put those five questions on a card and run them whenever a percentage appears. To test them under the clock, take the JobCannon SHL-style practice test, then work the weak spots on the numerical reasoning test. How to pace a timed reasoning test covers how long to spend. JobCannon is not affiliated with or endorsed by SHL Group Limited. SHL is a trademark of SHL Group Limited, and the result of this test is a practice score and not an official score.